← All posts

· 5 min read · Chesterfield

What Happens If the Appraisal Comes In Low? A Chesterfield Guide for Buyers and Sellers

A small wooden model house with a tape measure, a calculator and old brass keys on a table

The short answer

If the appraisal comes in below the price, the deal usually goes one of four ways: the seller lowers the price, the buyer covers the difference, the two meet in the middle, or the buyer walks away if the contract allows it. Sometimes the appraisal can also be challenged with better comparable sales.

A low appraisal is a negotiation, not a dead end. What you can do depends on what's written in your contract.

Christine Case is a REALTOR® with NextHome Advantage in Midlothian, Virginia, helping buyers and sellers in Chesterfield County and Metro Richmond understand their options before they make a move.

Why does the appraisal matter so much?

If the buyer is getting a loan, the lender orders an appraisal to check that the home is worth what they're lending against. The lender bases the loan on the lower of the price or the appraised value.

So if a home is under contract for one price and appraises for less, the lender won't simply lend more to make up the difference. Someone has to solve the gap. Your lender can explain exactly how it affects your loan.

What are the options when the appraisal comes in low?

1. The seller lowers the price to the appraised value. Simple and clean. Sellers often consider it when the next buyer's lender would likely see the same number.

2. The buyer covers the gap in cash. The buyer pays the difference out of pocket, on top of the down payment. Some buyers agree to this up front in the offer, with a limit. That's called an appraisal gap clause.

3. Meet in the middle. The seller comes down some, the buyer brings some extra cash. This is where a lot of these end up.

4. The buyer walks away. If the contract has an appraisal contingency and the buyer acts before its deadline, they can usually cancel and keep their earnest money. More on that here: Can a Buyer Back Out After the Seller Accepts an Offer in Virginia?

Can you challenge a low appraisal?

Sometimes. If the appraiser missed recent nearby sales that fit better, or got a fact wrong (square footage, bedrooms, a finished basement), the buyer's lender may accept a request to take another look. I pull the recent Chesterfield and Midlothian sales and the facts, and the lender decides whether to send it back to the appraiser.

It doesn't always change the number. It's still worth asking when the facts support it.

If you're the buyer, what should you decide first?

  • How much extra cash, if any, you're willing and able to bring.
  • Whether this house is still worth it to you at the higher price.
  • What your contract allows, and when that deadline is.

There's no wrong answer. The goal isn't a transaction. It's the right decision.

If you're the seller, what should you decide first?

  • Whether the next buyer's appraisal would likely come in about the same.
  • How much time and momentum a fresh start would cost you.
  • Whether a price adjustment, a credit, or a split makes more sense than going back on the market.

I'll show you the recent sales the appraisal used next to the ones I'd point to, so you can decide with the full picture.

How do you lower the chances of a low appraisal?

For sellers, it starts with pricing. A price backed by recent nearby sales gives the appraiser something solid to work with. For buyers in a competitive situation, it's knowing your limit before you write the offer, so an appraisal gap never catches you off guard.

Frequently asked questions

Does a low appraisal kill the deal?

Not usually. Most of the time the buyer and seller work out a new number.

Can I lose my earnest money if the appraisal is low?

If your contract has an appraisal contingency and you act before its deadline, you can usually cancel without losing your deposit. Without that contingency, the deposit can be at risk. Read your contract, or have me walk you through it. More here: How Much Earnest Money Do You Need in Virginia, and Can You Lose It?

Who pays for the appraisal?

Usually the buyer, as part of the loan process. Your lender can tell you the cost.

Do cash buyers need an appraisal?

Not for a lender, since there isn't one. Some cash buyers order one anyway for peace of mind.

Worried about the appraisal on your deal?

Let's look at the recent sales together and talk through your options before any deadline hits. Call or text me at (804) 381-1628, or send me a message.

Christine Case | REALTOR® | NextHome Advantage | Midlothian, VA

Christine Case, REALTOR®, smiling outdoors

Get my monthly local guide

Once a month, I send what's happening around Midlothian, Chesterfield and Metro Richmond, the local market in real numbers, and one useful thing to know before you buy or sell.

  • Local events and seasonal picks, like my Halloween map and pumpkin patch guide
  • Chesterfield County market numbers each month, explained step by step
  • One straight answer to a question buyers or sellers ask me

Free. One email a month. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy

Have a question about this? Ask me.

If something in this article raised a question about your own situation in Chesterfield, send it here. I read every message and answer it myself, with no pressure and no obligation.

Prefer to talk? Call or text (804) 381-1628.